With over a dozen integration platforms to choose from, it can be difficult to decide which is the right fit for your integration needs. Working with both Boomi and MuleSoft, we present our comparison.
We understand that picking the strongest platform for your implementation is a big deal. Whether Boomi or MuleSoft, both have built their reputation on integrating solutions. But which one is better? Boomi or MuleSoft?
Let’s establish one reality; both Boomi and MuleSoft are leading integration platforms on the market. Boomi focuses on integrating enterprise systems together, while MuleSoft’s Anypoint Platform by Salesforce (acquired in 2018) focuses on connecting cloud technologies together. Both have their pros and cons, but in the end both work in helping enterprise IT departments to connect rather than just being another vendor.
They are top-of-the-line integration platform that also provide other enterprise solutions such as orchestrating on-premises integrations, extending processes, and replicating data to the cloud. Both allow rapid development of applications for enterprise integration, with the added benefit of being able to manage those integrations from a single place. However, there are key differences in cost, performance, and overall features.
Getting down to brass tacks!
MuleSoft offers next-gen integration solutions that connect applications for a modern and advanced approach to data integration and API management. The company's Anypoint Platform can be used in heterogeneous environments, supporting both cloud and on-premise deployment options. It boasts of real-time processing capabilities, allowing businesses to easily adapt to changing conditions. Though, a point to be noted is that Anytime is not an integrated Solution. This necessitates purchasing fragments and piecing them together.
Some MuleSoft components you may have to purchase based on your project needs:
With Anypoint Studio, you can visually map, build, and deploy APIs to on-premises and cloud environments. You also gain the ability to edit and debug data integrations for a truly unique and unified experience.
Anypoint Connectors is a set of built-in connectors that a developer can use to integrate applications with thousands of third-party REST and SOAP, successfully taking care of the MuleSoft integration checklist.
Mulesoft Anytime brings together three platform components into one coherent, cloud-based solution: Anypoint Design Center, Anypoint Exchange and Anypoint Management Center. This single platform delivers a modern development experience complete with a cohesive set of APIs, templates and assets designed to lead customers through their digital transformation journey.
Boomi simplifies the way organizations integrate applications and data. Its innovative approach to integration removes the complexity of business processes between customers, businesses, partners and suppliers, improving performance and lowering costs. Boomi enables a business to transform itself into a truly connected organization, allowing real-time access and management of critical information assets. Though, one important check in Boomi’s box is that it is an all-in-one platform, not like MuleSoft.
The main components for Boomi’s Atomsphere include:
Application/ data integration: Boomi is the Industry Leading and first 100% Cloud-based Integration Platform. It connects any Combination of Cloud and On-premise Applications without Software or Coding.
API management: API Enabled Integration allows you to interact with multiple systems for event-based needs or real-time updates. API Integration and automation also ensure data integrity across your stack, without having to worry about versioning issues.
B2B/EDI management: Boomi’s low code development solution, enables companies to manage B2B integrations, EDI partner onboarding, and integrate EDI with zero glitches.
Master data management: Robust Master Data Management (hub) makes it easier to manage the consistency and quality of data which is replicated across multiple systems or applications.
Flow: It builds and automates workflows for businesses.
How do these reigning leaders compare?
Their build approach:
Both Boomi and MuleSoft are developing solutions at different levels of the architecture, down to the development stack. When it comes to choosing one over the other, we believe it’s most important to understand how your business needs to process data. For example, if you need a single solution for providing data from any system into multiple target systems then Boomi is a good fit. Or if you require a uniform approach to create custom interfaces with high performance and familiarity across on-premises and cloud-based services then MuleSoft could be for you.
It doesn’t hurt to know that these two are built on two distinct frameworks; MuleSoft being an API-driven network while Boomi finds itself in a traditional ETL middleware approach. This may seemingly give an edge to MuleSoft with the ability to span connections across multiple apps and systems, so it creates, recreates, reuses components using less code.
As for boomi vs mulesoft API management, MuleSoft clearly is a better choice, allowing users to deal with issues in real time with the help of its API manager.
Boomi and MuleSoft Features:
Boomi is a Cloud Native Integration Platform that features high flexibility, reliability and security allowing enterprises to innovate rapidly. Plus, it goes with a range of cloud-based operations.
MuleSoft on the other hand has on premise integration system with a variety of products to boost. However, it’s very similitude legacy system can be cumbersome for businesses as they will need to continually install hardware and server.
Furthermore, Boomi’s unified runtime is built for integration. Boomi’s runtime includes a smart engine that enables all infrastructure and integrations to be centralized in the cloud without any complicated IT setup. And all these integrations are visible through the centralized Boomi Atomsphere.
MuleSoft’s core architecture is based legacy which processes messages and performs actions in a batch fashion. Furthermore, their system cannot support the Artificial Intelligence Machine Learning capabilities due to the inability to access metadata of accounts for predictive analysis. This largely limits MuleSoft from stepping ahead of Boomi’s sonic deployment and edge computing capabilities.
The Platform and the Performance:
Boomi is a simplified and scalable platform that helps companies operationalize their business processes. Boomi enables businesses to execute complex process in a simple, fast, cost-effective, and consistent manner. Boomi’s seamless integration with cloud components such as storage, messaging, access control, analytics and security services reduces development time, improves performance and core functionality, while increasing flexibility and extensibility.
The MuleSoft platform needs an expert at hand as its code-based development can get complex for a non-developer.
About the Connectors:
MuleSoft allows you to integrate with different platforms in a distributed way to update data. The real power comes from its granular replication feature to update data. It supports approximately 300 connectors to databases, Storage resources, network services, and SaaS platforms.
Boomi replicates data changes one at a time across different systems and supports two kinds of connectors - application and technology connectors. Developers can write custom connectors with its connector SDK.
|Coding||Low Code||Complex coding|
|Smart Data Mapping||Yes||No|
|Versioning||Built-in version control||6 different versions of a Runtime Engine|
|Database Replica||Full Table||Depends on manually written SELECT statements|
|Pre-built SaaS Sources||~80||~70|
|Dataware house connections||Yes||No|
|Developer Tools||AtomSphere API, Connector SDK for writing custom connectors||Runtime Manager REST API, CloudHub API|
|Pricing Model||Monthly or Annually||Annually|
In this battle of MuleSoft vs Boomi, we conclude that both are enterprise-grade Integration Platforms. MuleSoft was developed and standardized as an on-premises software. However, Boomi eliminates the need of standard IT infrastructure and skillset required in deploying data integration application unlike MuleSoft, which to be fair has a robust training network to compensate for all the technical appendage needed.
About the Author
Sanoobar Shaikh, Associate - Content Strategist Marketing
Sanoobar is a Content Strategist at Jade Global working and engaging with a diverse range of material and literature, and interacting with SME's from different industries and verticals. She comes with 13+ years of experience, in writing, and teaching, working in Academia, Advertising, Wellness, and IT. She has donned several roles in her career span, from a teacher, copy writer, communications specialists, script writer, to an editor, always in the pursuit of creating content that strikes a chord with the reader and brings value.
At Jade Global, she oversees content strategy, planning and creation for print, media, research, and marketing collateral, campaigns etc. She is also a research scholar and a published writer, en route to pursuing her PhD.